Explorations in Next Generation Internet
EU Engineroom focuses on identifying and evaluating the key enabling technologies and topics that will underpin the Next Generation Internet in 2025.
Engineroom’s three key pillars:

Developing a cutting-edge data-driven methodology for identifying early signals of new trends & technologies.

Mapping the ecosystems & networks surrounding these key topics, evaluating their social, legal, technological, ethical & economic contexts.

Creating a value-driven vision for what the future internet could and should look like, involving a wide variety of voices across Europe.

Consortium's partners:


Unique terms: 0+

Media articles: 0
Scientific articles: 0

Reddit comments: 0
Wikipedia edges: 0
Meetup groups: 0+

Articles analysis period: three years and two months

Why ArXiv, SSRN and ACM?

  • Lengthy publication process in scientific journals
  • Broad coverage: SSRN's e-Library provides over 800,000 research papers from 400,000 researchers across 30 disciplines, ArXiv provides open access to almost 1,500,000 e-prints mostly in STEM fields
  • ACM is world’s largest computing society, with more than 100,000 members outside the US, more than 1,000,000 papers and 6000 institutions

Project Goal and General Idea

  • Major aim is to identify key technologies determining the development of Internet until 2025
  • Strong focus on the relationship between technological areas and social issues
  • Data-driven approach with heterogeneous sources of data

Trend analysis

  • Analysis based on the frequency of appearances for all unigrams and bigrams in the texts
  • Average monthly change in the analysed term's frequency is calculated by OLS regressions
  • The coefficient reveals the trending unigrams and bigrams

Co-occurrence analysis

  • Exploring the relationship between topics
  • Pairs of terms which are mentioned together in media articles
  • The number of articles containing both terms is divided by the number of articles including our previously identified keyword of interest for every media website

Issue mapping

  • Articles are categorised across two dimensions: geography (EU vs US) and covered topic (social vs technological)
  • Words are ranked based on their frequency in articles classified as social and non-social (technological)

Landscape mapping

  • Identifying key stakeholders and examining relative strengths in the field of emerging technologies across the world
  • Research clusters: network analysis based on author affiliations of academic papers
  • Meetups: geographical analysis on the evolution of Meetup groups across countries

Wikipedia network analysis

  • Matching the keywords to Wikipedia articles and parsing their text to extract hyperlinks
  • Generating the network of hyperlinks that connects the articles with one another
  • Using a community detection algorithm (the Louvain method) to identify clusters of nodes

Main Programming Tools

Topic identification

172 most trending NGI related keywords are identified

Grouped into 20 wider areas
The size of the bubble is based on the regression coefficient
Bigger bubble: more robust trend

The goal is to dive deeper in emerging technologies'
Relationship between social issues and technology
These pairs frequently appear together in articles (media articles) or are used in comments about a topic (reddit)

These maps show organisations working in the 10 challenge areas we identified under as part of Engineroom. Our mapping is far from complete, so please feel free to get in touch and share additional organisations

All maps open in new tab

Access Cyber Diversity Ethical AI Fake news Identity Power Right to opt-out Sovereignty Sustainability

Aim of the study

The aim of this qualitative study was to analyze the media narratives surrounding emerging internet technologies (understood in broad terms, as technologies, applications, solutions, internet phenomena) in online magazines devoted to tech and futurology. Media narratives are defined as a way events (and stories) are composed to be presented to an audience.

The key questions were:

  • What are the most common media narratives on emerging technologies?
  • Are those narratives predominantly optimistic/pessimistic/positive/negative/neutral/argumentative/informational?
  • Are there any recurring phrases (synonyms, antonyms, euphemisms, associations, etc.) which appear in media narratives focused on emerging technologies?

Read qualitative content
analysis report (PDF)

263 kB, opens in new tab

Short topic list

Hover on a topic to show keywords and a short description

& Trust
& Resilience
Internet & Data Sovereignty

The Cambridge Analytica revelations have made it abundantly clear how little control we have as consumers over our own personal data, and the way the internet operates more generally. Building solutions and new models that allow citizens to understand the increasingly more complex processes behind dominant internet applications should therefore be a key component of a more democratic NGI. Experimentation with encrypted data boxes and data commons, as well as fostering more citizen involvement in, for example, internet governance processes and technology development would need to be a part of this, as would moving production of these technologies back into Europe.

Linked keywords:
open internet, net neutrality, personal data, cambridge analytica, identity theft, black box, ai research
A Safe, Accessible & Diverse Internet

Before we can talk about building a next generation internet, we need to ensure that all Europeans can have access to the current generation of the internet - that means investing in infrastructure, multilingual and accessible tools (targeting for example less tech savvy or lesser-abled users), but also creating a safe environment for all (particularly as online harassment and hostility particularly affect more vulnerable groups). Increasing diversity in who gets to build and use the internet is important if we want to ensure we don’t perpetuate existing inequalities also in the digital economy, but also helps stimulate innovation, as diverse teams tend to be more creative.

Linked keywords:
hate speech, alt-right, extremist content, sexism, gender discrimination, #metoo, child safety, trafficking, parental control, youtube kids, diversity, racism, accessibility, 5G networks, care robots, voice assistants and chatbots, online safety
Online Identities & Trust

If Europe were able to build a trustworthy and secure system for managing online identities, offering an e-ID to every European citizen (not unlike the incredibly successful Estonian model), the continent would be able to take a massive leap ahead in strengthening e-commerce and other relationship-based online interactions. Effective identity management wouldn’t only increase trust on the internet (who am I really talking to? Can I trust the online service?) and so bolster the European digital economy, but would also help us build more personal online relationships. The currently dominant rate-and-review system places a lot of power in the hands of the reviewer (a single low score on ride sharing app can seriously damage a driver’s ability to attract new customers), e-identity systems could make these interactions more positive and equal.

Linked keywords:
smart contracts, distributed ledgers, facial recognition, digital assistant, voice assistant
Cybersecurity and Resilience

One key component of building a more democratic and inclusive Next Generation Internet is ensuring the infrastructures underpinning the internet itself are secure, safe and resilient. We live in a time of growing cyber threats: from rising cyber crime to ever more sophisticated cyber warfare capabilities. Existing weaknesses and flaws in the internet’s physical infrastructure and protocols also require urgent mending. Governments, the private sector and citizens need access to the right tools and information to help them protect themselves against these kinds of threats, and larger systems changes are required to ensure our (critical) infrastructures are resilient in the face of merging challenges such as quantum computing-enabled cracking of encryption.

Linked keywords:
cybersecurity, ransomware, cyberwar, cyber threats, meltdown, nonpetya, hacking, quantum computing, encryption, critical infrastructure, autonomous weapons, killer robots, equifax
Ethical AI & ML

As discussions about the potential transformative impact of AI and Machine Learning have come to dominate public debate in recent years, so have concerns about the potential negative side-effects of allowing these kinds of technologies to play an ever-larger role in decision-making and the governing of our societies. The development of ethical AI and ML tools doesn’t only involve the use of responsibly managed data (make sure we have a representative sample, privacy and anonymity is ensured) and algorithms that don’t further existing societal biases (around gender and ethnicity, for example), but also that the tools themselves are used for purposes we consider ethically just. Ensuring we have solutions that are fair and inclusive along the value chain (from data generation to the impact of the decisions being made or tasks replaced).

Linked keywords:
machine learning, deep learning, algorithmic bias, algorithmic accountability, artificial intelligence, black box, open AI, data lakes, transparency
Trustworthy Online Media and Information Ecosystems

The proliferation of “fake news” and the weaponisation of information is a key challenge for the internet today, threatening the fundaments of our democracies and even societies. Ensuring access to trustworthy information, and preventing the deliberate manipulation of information flows without resorting to censorship and hampering of freedom of speech remains an unsolved challenge however. Under this topic, we would explore potential solutions for specific issues such as fake news bots and preventing filter bubbles, but also take a wider view in trying to strengthen (social) media ecosystems and exploring alternative sustainable business models for quality news and information provision.

Linked keywords:
smart contracts, distributed ledgers, facial recognition, digital assistant, voice assistant
The Right to Opt out & Self-Govern

With the internet becoming ever more pervasive in our lives and societies, shaping our jobs, our cities, our interactions with the government and so forth, it has become harder and harder for individuals to shape our relationships with, or opt out of “the internet” altogether. With the rise of the smart city, and the millions of connected IoT-devices that will underpin it tracking our every move, how do we ensure citizens can meaningfully consent to what happens with the data they generate, and retain their privacy? With everything from our smart vacuums to credit card companies collecting and selling our data to the highest bidder (through very opaque processes), we need new solutions that help citizens give informed consent, as well as the ability to completely opt out of being part of, for example, data sharing systems, while still being able to use key services.

Linked keywords:
privacy, informed consent, smart cities, self-driving cars, facial recognition, social credit, Internet of Things, surveillance, data brokers
Decentralising Power

Most of the issues the internet faces today are a direct consequence of the increased monopolization of the internet, and the business models that sustain this dynamic - and when not, at the very least are more complicated to address because so few actors have the power to do so. We urgently require new business models that can provide an alternative to the reigning advertising-supported model, and can sustain a more pluralistic and healthy digital economy. Alternative models, such as platform cooperativism or blockchain-enabled micropayments systems can help empower smaller players, help level the playing field and offer better protections to consumers and digital workers. We need to support initiatives and SMEs that operate under these alternative models, through policy (protecting net neutrality, designing next generation competition and antitrust policy) and funding support.

Linked keywords:
open internet, net neutrality, free speech, internet freedom, gig economy, ico, worker's rights, tech giants, distributed ledgers, consumer protection
A Sustainable Internet

One key challenge for the internet moving forward is ensuring that the hardware and infrastructures underpinning it are sustainable and can meaningfully contribute to building a more circular economy. The challenges around the internet’s environmental footprint are myriad: from the extraordinary amount of energy used by data centres and emerging technologies like blockchain, to the costly mining processes behind the materials making our tech devices function. Though there is a growing recognition of these issues, we do not yet see enough solutions - this is we think a space where Europe can start to play an important front-runner role.

Linked keywords:
blockchain, cryptocurrency, smart devices, energy efficiency, mining, renewable energy, data storage
Online Media
Opt out &
A Sustainable

Issue mapping

Articles are classified in two dimensions: EU/US, social issue/technology

EU axis: articles from European sources or concerning Europe, residualized on the social issues axis
Social issues axis: articles containing words from a pre-defined list of social topics based on Latent Dirichlet Allocation
Mapping trending words with article type based on no. of occurrences
Top right corner: EU articles on social issues
Bottom left corner: US articles on technology

The sentiment analysis resulted in a compound score for every paragraph containing a given phrase. The score is calculated from the mean of the valence scores of each word in the paragraph apart from the analysed words themselves, which have been removed from the paragraph's text
tech workers
Mark Zuckerberg
facial recognition
work conditions
location data
Chinese tech

Most positiveMost negative
5g spectrumcomment system
5g technologyyork attorney
vpn servicefake comments
5g networkjessica rosenworcel
machine learningneutrality repeal


Most positiveMost negative
blockchain platformbomb threat
private blockchainspying agency
climate changeransomware outbreak
artificial intelligencenational health
blockchain startupfall victim

tech workers

Most positiveMost negative
station farbitrary agreement
tech ecosystemsexual misconduct
tech nationforced arbitration
british capitalsexual harassment
user datafull-time employee

Mark Zuckerberg

Most positiveMost negative
jeff bezoscontent moderation
machine learninghate speech
artificial intelligencedamian collins
climate changeelection interference
facebook appfake account

facial recognition

Most positiveMost negative
thunderbolt 3privacy standards
google homeborder guard
note 8watch list
google assistantautonomous weapon
wireless chargingbrother watch


Most positiveMost negative
data managementbritish airways
machine learningcybersecurity serious
digital marketelectronic health
process datafacial recognition
explicit consenthate speech

work conditions

Most positiveMost negative
amazon alexaagainst tesla
smart officehate speech
artificial intelligencetesla worker
industry leaderprotest over
organized effortfull-time employee

location data

Most positiveMost negative
digital markethome office
artificial intelligencebounty hunter
data sciencelocation aggregation
google homecustom location
machine learningajit pai

Chinese tech

Most positiveMost negative
ai capableface extradition
ai researchuncle sam
machine learningimmediate release
artificial intelligencemeng wanzhou
5g smartphonetrade secret



The video shows how Meetups have spread across the entire EU, and also the rest of the continent
Inside the EU, the largest Meetup communities are located in such core tech clusters as London, Paris, Munich or Berlin. Moreover, vibrant communities can be found in Lisbon, Warsaw and Dublin
Outside the EU, focal points include Istanbul, Kiev and Moscow

Cyan – AI and machine learning; magenta – web development and JavaScript; yellow – agile communities on

Circle radius depends on current number of group members.

As Meetup was founded in the US, it had been less widespread until 2014-2015 in Europe. However, in 2018 the number of EU Meetups in chosen areas surpassed the US
Groups around web development and AI are more much more popular than agile in the US, while in the EU the 3 groups are similar in number. The share of AI groups is similarly increasing across both sides of the Atlantic: in 2011, AI was the smallest group, while in the last year it almost surpassed the most popular Web group
The figures compare EU member states regarding their shares of Meetup groups located in the EU across the 3 different technological areas. The top 3 countries across all categories include Germany (DE), Great Britain (GB), and France (FR). Other countries with strong communities in all areas are: Spain (ES - especially in AI), the Netherlands (NL), and Poland (PL). Ireland (IE) appears in AI communities, Italy in AI and Web, Romania in Web, Sweden (SE) and Belgium (BE) in Agile
A general trend that can be observed is the expansion of Meetup groups to new locations between 2011-2014 and relatively constant differences between countries since then

Research hubs

The map presents the countries with institutions that are publishing in journals related to ACM
The table shows the top 5 institutions by country, based on the number of publications in the ACM Digital Library. The map confirms that ACM has a global presence

Click to open interactive map in new tab, then hover on country to show table

Map of countries with table
The top 2 institutions overall are located in the EU: Karlsruhe Institute of Technology and University of Toulouse. From the top 10, the sole US based institution is Google Inc, while the remaining 7 are all located in China
The presented maps show the clusters of institutions whose affiliated researchers were likely to publish together
5 maps were prepared: one based on SSRN data, and 4 based on ACM, also taking into consideration the different research areas

Click to open interactive map in new tab

Map of clusters

Clusters in categories: AI Social (ACM) Social (SSRN) Tech (open in new tab)
For a better assessment of the EU’s relative position in research, the aggregate results of the 28 EU member countries is compared to other countries
The figures show that the overall EU28 research output is the largest across all categories
The top 10 contributors to ACM are: EU28, US, China, Japan, India, Taiwan, Australia, South Korea, Canada, Taiwan and Brazil.


In order to identify main topics in the tech press corpus we have performed a topic modeling exercise with a help of popular LDA algorithm. On the media dataset we have performed document clustering using tf-idf, multidimensional scaling, k-means and pyLDAvis.


Topic clusters identified using LDA algorithm

Archive version – 20 topics, SSRN working paper



EU ENGINEROOM has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Grant Agreement no 780643. The content of this website does not represent the opinion of the European Union, and the European Union is not responsible for any use that might be made of such content.

Zenodo: data GitLab: codes

Toggle presentation mode
Click to show extended description